I have been brought up in the Jewish faith. That means I have been taught, and teach others, about the extensive customs, rituals and traditions that the living do when a person dies. How we treat and take care of the body, what we wear to show we are in mourning, why we have funerals and say prayers; were all part of what I have been brought up to know. However, in Judaism, at least in my experience, we are not taught about what happens to the person who has died. Sure, we know that their body no longer goes on living and we are taught to believe in the neshama, the soul, going somewhere else to await the arrival of the messiah. But we do not know where that place is. Unlike in Christianity we do not speak of Heaven only of the heavens. For that reason, as well as others, I find it hard to identify with the idea of my child as an angel. I cannot picture her with feathery wings laying on a cloud somewhere high above us all.
This loss of faith has left an even deeper emptiness that adds further isolation to what I have already been experiencing. I, therefore started asking friends what they believed happened to a person when they died. I heard touching stories of dreams of their loved ones assuring them everything would be alright, of feeling a person's presence in the wind, of signs their loved one had sent in the way of orbs or hearts and so many other stories that were meant to warm and reassure me. But I didn't feel reassured. I felt lowly. I have not experienced any of those things. And so I began to feel that I was undeserving of such a feeling of peace and connection. Some might assume that I have not been exposed to those types of experiences because I have been "closed" to the idea of such signs, yet I feel as if the opposite were true. I so desperately have wanted some evidence that Celia's soul had survived and she forgave me for not being able to save her.
Yesterday I went walking. As I walked, I tried to keep my mind occupied by listening to an audio book. If you ask me what it was about, I would be unable to tell you as all I could concentrate on was what the next day, what is now today, meant. April 2, 2013 would be, is, six months to the day since Celia died. This amount of time seems significant to me. I am sure, had she lived, instead of writing and sharing this blog, I would be sharing photos of her smiley face with some sign showing everyone that my baby was six months old today. I would take pride in all the "ooh'ss and aww's" of how adorable my daughter was. But instead of pictures of my six-month-old to share I have a six month old memory of loss, trauma and heartbreak. My journey, so far, may be difficult for others to witness. I understand. Watching a person deep in grief, misery, shame, and guilt. It must be difficult to bear witness to such seemingly self-distructive behavior. As I walked, I thought of all these things. Then, as I came upon my house I noticed a cluster of purplish-blue flowers blooming under what would have been Celia's side window. I have lived in this house for seven years and have not once seen such a flower in or around my yard. I sat next to the cluster of flowers and began to cry.
"Celia" I whispered softly as the tears flowed. Could this be the sign that I had been searching for or could it be some figment that I have created to ease my suffering? I suppose I could choose either answer, but I choose to believe that these beautiful little flowers came from my daughter. I choose to believe that she sent them here just for me. After taking a few photographs, I continued with my day.
When evening fell I listened in on a teleconference designed to help grieving mothers and the people who support them move forward with their lives. I found it to be unhelpful and began to again feel the dagger of loss in my chest. "What are your biggest challenges to healing?" The professional on the other end of the phone asked. She instructed us to write two of these challenges down and be as specific as possible. I did not even have to take a moment to think. I instantly knew my biggest challenges were: 1) My incomparable sense of guilt over the death of my daughter. If it had been my body that failed, then how could I move beyond that. If it had been my midwife that failed, and I am not asserting this to be the case, then I am the one who chose her, so truly that was my failing too. All the roads of what if's lead back to me. 2) Feeling pressured or shamed by other people's timelines and judgements, whether or not those judgements were true or simply my own perception or projection. And 3) I have no desire to truly live. I have no intentions of ending my life, but the idea that I should "move on" or be in the world knowing what could have been, what was supposed to have been, and is no longer, seemed impossible.
Somewhere in the abstruse teleconference land, was another woman, who through our losses has become a dear friend. She too had found the teleconference to be unhelpful. I believe the term she used to describe the content was "plastic." Instead of ending the eve of Celia's six month birth day with the uncomfortable, plastic words of a stranger, I chose to confide in my friend, Camilla. "Tomorrow it will have been six months," I pointed out "and a Tuesday." Celia was born and died on a Tuesday, my first surgery was on a Tuesday, I was readmitted to the hospital with an infection to undergo more surgeries on a Tuesday, on a Tuesday, on a Tuesday, on a Tuesday. It seemed as if the day were always going to be a day full of suffering.
Camilla offered empathetic words and then simply stated "That's your day...your's and Celia's..." Until that moment I truly hadn't thought about the day in that way. Yes, Tuesday was the day I lost her, but it was also the day I got to hold her in my arms.
I went on to lament of the cemetery being closed, the brick not yet being installed at the zoo. Then I remembered the cluster of flowers beneath the window. I sent the picture to Camilla and told her what I have already told you of their origins. Camilla immediately identified the flowers "Blue Siclla...beautiful" she went on to research the meaning of the sign my daughter had sent. "Forgive and forget," was the message she had found. She feared the discovery of the message would upset me. The forget part was certainly curious. I began to wonder. I started analyzing the easy one, forgive. I am sure if I am to live a life at all I will need to move towards forgiving myself. I will also need to be forgiving of others. The cliche' words some speak, the way in which some have retreated from my side, and yes, even the cruel things that have been uttered will all, in time, need to be forgiven. The harder half of the message, forget, was strange in this situation. Or was it? I was never going to to forget my daughter, so that could not possibly be what was meant or what it would mean to me. Perhaps forget was meant in the way of letting go. Not, of course, letting go of my daughter, but in the letting go of the drowning pain I feel. Letting go of the harsh words that I have snorted to myself and others have spoken to me. As my mind raced to analyze such a message Camilla continued her research of the meaning of this flower. "Bluebell," she informed "is another name that covers many types of scilla. They symbolize humility associated with constancy, gratitude and everlasting love." By this point in our conversation Camilla and I were both in tears. Though these tears were different. For the first time the tears I shed did come with the searing pain of loss. Rather, they were a comfort a reminder of the love that I have for my child and the love she would have had and seemingly does have for me. I was becoming incredibly warmed by these flowers. Scilla, when uttered, even sounds a little like Celia. Camilla went on to find Cicely Mary Barker's Scilla Fairy. She is a coy little sprite who comes with these words:
Blue Scilla from Celia |
When evening fell I listened in on a teleconference designed to help grieving mothers and the people who support them move forward with their lives. I found it to be unhelpful and began to again feel the dagger of loss in my chest. "What are your biggest challenges to healing?" The professional on the other end of the phone asked. She instructed us to write two of these challenges down and be as specific as possible. I did not even have to take a moment to think. I instantly knew my biggest challenges were: 1) My incomparable sense of guilt over the death of my daughter. If it had been my body that failed, then how could I move beyond that. If it had been my midwife that failed, and I am not asserting this to be the case, then I am the one who chose her, so truly that was my failing too. All the roads of what if's lead back to me. 2) Feeling pressured or shamed by other people's timelines and judgements, whether or not those judgements were true or simply my own perception or projection. And 3) I have no desire to truly live. I have no intentions of ending my life, but the idea that I should "move on" or be in the world knowing what could have been, what was supposed to have been, and is no longer, seemed impossible.
Somewhere in the abstruse teleconference land, was another woman, who through our losses has become a dear friend. She too had found the teleconference to be unhelpful. I believe the term she used to describe the content was "plastic." Instead of ending the eve of Celia's six month birth day with the uncomfortable, plastic words of a stranger, I chose to confide in my friend, Camilla. "Tomorrow it will have been six months," I pointed out "and a Tuesday." Celia was born and died on a Tuesday, my first surgery was on a Tuesday, I was readmitted to the hospital with an infection to undergo more surgeries on a Tuesday, on a Tuesday, on a Tuesday, on a Tuesday. It seemed as if the day were always going to be a day full of suffering.
Camilla offered empathetic words and then simply stated "That's your day...your's and Celia's..." Until that moment I truly hadn't thought about the day in that way. Yes, Tuesday was the day I lost her, but it was also the day I got to hold her in my arms.
I went on to lament of the cemetery being closed, the brick not yet being installed at the zoo. Then I remembered the cluster of flowers beneath the window. I sent the picture to Camilla and told her what I have already told you of their origins. Camilla immediately identified the flowers "Blue Siclla...beautiful" she went on to research the meaning of the sign my daughter had sent. "Forgive and forget," was the message she had found. She feared the discovery of the message would upset me. The forget part was certainly curious. I began to wonder. I started analyzing the easy one, forgive. I am sure if I am to live a life at all I will need to move towards forgiving myself. I will also need to be forgiving of others. The cliche' words some speak, the way in which some have retreated from my side, and yes, even the cruel things that have been uttered will all, in time, need to be forgiven. The harder half of the message, forget, was strange in this situation. Or was it? I was never going to to forget my daughter, so that could not possibly be what was meant or what it would mean to me. Perhaps forget was meant in the way of letting go. Not, of course, letting go of my daughter, but in the letting go of the drowning pain I feel. Letting go of the harsh words that I have snorted to myself and others have spoken to me. As my mind raced to analyze such a message Camilla continued her research of the meaning of this flower. "Bluebell," she informed "is another name that covers many types of scilla. They symbolize humility associated with constancy, gratitude and everlasting love." By this point in our conversation Camilla and I were both in tears. Though these tears were different. For the first time the tears I shed did come with the searing pain of loss. Rather, they were a comfort a reminder of the love that I have for my child and the love she would have had and seemingly does have for me. I was becoming incredibly warmed by these flowers. Scilla, when uttered, even sounds a little like Celia. Camilla went on to find Cicely Mary Barker's Scilla Fairy. She is a coy little sprite who comes with these words:
Scilla, Scilla tell me true,
Why are you se very blue?
Oh, I really cannot say
Why I'm made this lovely way!
I might know if I were wise.
Yet-I've heard of seas and skies,
Where the blie is deeper far
Than our skies of Springtime are.
P'r'aps I'm here to let you see
What that Summer blue will be.
When you see it, think of me!
Cicely Mary Barker
Am I cured now? No, I cannot say that I am. But am I better? Yes, for the first time, in six months, I am better than yesterday.
Dear Lisa, Your honest, poignant and so deeply personal representation of your grieving and your inner world is, to me, such a tribute to your courage and your powerful drive for healing. It touches me to my core in more ways than I can quantify. I am so grateful for who you are, and for your example in my life. And I am so fervently rooting for you, for both your healing and your right to heal in your way. Your words are so incredibly potent. I love you so much.
ReplyDeleteI had so many thoughts connected to so many of your comments, I couldn't even figure out where to start. But I relate so closely to your questions of guilt, responsibility and forgiveness. I worked so hard last semester on this kind of issue re my sister's drowning in 1975. I concluded that work without a feeling of healing, but with an understanding that the weight of that sense of responsibility is utterly overwhelming... and whether I was completely responsible can be argued. Some people truly are responsible for another's death; vastly more people assume their piece of potential responsibility at a much higher level than corresponds to the reality. I've learned by watching people over the years, that when there's an untimely death, everybody who cares soul-searches about the things they wish they had done to prevent it. The question for me is, how do I tell the truth about what happened, absorb and atone for my sense of responsibility, and move forward with the sense of tolerance (and even forgiveness) for myself that I would ALWAYS extend to any other person? And that I so want for you. I honor your grappling with that question for yourself, at the same time that I personally would NEVER hold you responsible in ANY WAY. It doesn't resonate with my understanding of what happened, and I don't think it's your rightful burden. xx oo
ReplyDeleteThis is so touching, Lisa. I wanted to share a definition of "forgiveness" with you. You might have already heard it, but Oprah talked about it on her show and it really resonated with me (I know, how cheesy...) I never understood how some things could ever be forgiven. How could someone who has been raped, for example, forgive their attacker? The definition that I am speaking of goes something like that: "Forgiveness is giving up the hope that the past could be any different. It is not accepting what has happened to you, but accepting that it has happened to you. Not accepting that it was OK for it to happen, but accepting that it has happened" Not an easy thing to do by any means, but in my opinion, it makes more sense than thinking that we need to be OK with some of the tragic things that happen in our lives. I hope that this makes as much sense to you as it does to me. I am sending you lots of love, Lisa. (This is Stella from NAMI, I didn't have an option to just write my name...)
ReplyDeleteLisa,
ReplyDeleteI struggle to find words - I simply want you to know that My heart feels for you. I'm so happy for you to have received the flowers, the sign, and that you finally had a relatively better day.
P.s. this is Mel from NAMI
ReplyDeleteWow. Just beautiful.
ReplyDeleteBeautiful... touching... and hopeful.
ReplyDeleteJust wanted to send you some love. I have loss of different sorts and there is screaming inside of me.
ReplyDeleteI now live 3000 miles away, but I used to be a Title 1 teacher in Detroit (too). Sending you lots n lots n lots of love.